Not sure if you have seen this thread, but lots of opinions on a lot of different hotels, have a read through, i think there are so many good places that i dont have any particular favourite.
http://www.phuket-info.com/forums/ac...esthouses.html
I think in all my trips to Phuket i would have to say that my stay in Patong Villa was the best, but that was due to the people staying there at the time, also having a swimming pool about 5 steps from the front door was excellent.
Not sure why i am writing about patong villa as i believe it not to be guest friendly anymore, but i just like writing sometimes.